| First-Team All-American |
| 1957 |
Bob Hastings ’57 |
3B |
| 1958 |
Frankie Saia
|
1B |
| 1964 |
Tom Stephenson ’64 (.333) |
1B |
| 1965 |
Joe O’Donnell ’67 (.378) |
1B |
| 1968 |
Dick Manchester ’68 (.467) |
2B |
| 1969 |
John Ignacio ’69 (.448) |
OF |
| 1970 |
Dan DeMichele ’71 (.421) |
OF |
| 1971 |
Pete Varney ’71 (.326) |
C |
| 1973 |
Jim Stoeckel ’74 (.335) |
3B |
| 1978 |
Mike Stenhouse ’80 (.500) |
OF |
| 1979 |
Mike Stenhouse ’80 (.417) |
OF |
| 1980 |
Charlie Santos-Buch ’80 (.444) |
OF |
| 1983 |
Don Allard ’83 (.414) |
OF |
| 1984 |
Jim DePalo ’87 (.423) |
C |
| |
Bruce Weller ’84 (.418) |
OF |
| 1985 |
Jeff Musselman ’85 (6-0) |
P |
| 1987 |
Mike Pakalnis ’87 (.431) |
SS |
| 2003 |
Zak Farkes '06 (.308) (Freshman)
|
2B |
| 2007 |
Max Perlman ’11 (5-1) (Freshman)
|
P |
| Second-Team
All-American |
| 1985 |
Mickey Maspons ’85 (.491) |
DH/U |
| 2002 |
Ben Crockett ’02 (6-4) |
P |
| Third Team/ Honorable Mention
All-American |
| 1978 |
Larry Brown ’79 (5-0) |
P |
| 1999 |
Andrew Huling ’99 (.463) |
OF |
| |
Josh Klimkiewicz ’06 (.317) |
1B |
| First-Team CoSIDA Academic
All-American |
| 1999 |
Andrew Huling ’99 |
|
| Second-Team CoSIDA Academic
All-American |
| 1986 |
Bobby Kay ’86 |
|
